Carrie: Collector's Edition [Blu-ray]
Blu-ray A - America - Shout! Factory
Review written by and copyright: Anthony Arrigo (7th December 2016).
The Film

Adaptations of Stephen King’s literary works are often a gamble; some features are outright classics, while others stumble so badly they remain notorious flops for years to come (“Dreamcatcher” (2003), anyone?). To be fair, the bar for King’s page-to-picture legacy was set awfully high when a then-relatively-unknown Brian De Palma adapted the 1974 novel “Carrie” to great acclaim. His film, “Carrie” (1976), visualized King’s words via an artistic lens that is still, to this day, considered one of the finest works of horror ever produced for the screen. All of De Palma’s signature screen tricks are on display, giving “Carrie” a unique visual aesthetic that easily set it apart from most of the 70's horror fare. King’s novel, meanwhile, has proved to be a wellspring of entertainment, responsible not only for De Palma’s film but for a TV remake, a sequel, a remake, a musical, and a stage play. All of these pale in comparison to De Palma’s vision, and no matter how much Hollywood tries the magic of this movie simply can’t be replicated.

Social outcast Carrie White (Sissy Spacek) is unquestionably the least popular girl in school. The classmates who do notice her can’t stand her, while the rest of the school – administrators included – can’t even be bothered to get her name right. Her mother, Margaret (Piper Laurie), is a religious whacko who finds sin in everything, admonishing all around her. When a distraught Carrie freaks out after getting her first period in the school showers, her classmates ruthlessly taunt her until she is reduced to a blubbering pile of tears. Carrie finds no solace at home, either, when her mother punishes her for becoming a woman, convinced her menstruation is nothing more than the work of Satan. Carrie is ordered to pray within a small closet, where the creepiest tiny statue of Jesus ever committed to film is enshrined. The only person who shows any sympathy toward Carrie is her gym teacher, Miss Collins (Betty Buckley), and even she finds the girl to be trying at times. Disturbed by the lack of empathy shown by Carrie’s fellow students, Ms. Collins orders the gym class to endure three weeks of detention on the fields, running and exercising, or else they’ll be suspended and denied permission to attend the prom. Everyone falls in line except for Chris (Nancy Allen), who gets a firm slap across the face for her refusal.

At least one student seems to feel remorse: Sue Snell (Amy Irving). In a bid to improve Carrie’s feelings, Sue asks her boyfriend, Tommy (William Katt), to invite Carrie to the prom. He agrees but convincing Carrie isn’t as easy; she rejects him repeatedly, positive his charm is a ruse, until finally agreeing when pushed. Things seem like they’re beginning to turn around for Carrie, and even though her mother is extremely disapproving of her going to the prom for once Carrie begins to act on her own accord. Margaret warns her that “they’re all gonna laugh at you” but Carrie rebuffs her words. This is one instance where she maybe should have heeded her mother’s caution because while Carrie is determined to have a fun night for the first time in her life, Chris and her meatball boyfriend, Billy (John Travolta), have something sinister planned. Little does anyone know that Carrie is more than just a meek loner, and soon the true nature of her hidden power is about to be unhinged.

The greatest success of “Carrie” is how humanistic it is, with the devastating drama making Carrie’s journey all the more tragic. Carrie possesses powers unknown and unclear – even to her – and the only time they are revealed is when someone has wronged her. Unfortunately, that happens virtually every day. She’s a sheltered young woman, ignorant to normalcy because her mother is a zealot hell-bent on preaching the gospel and worshiping the Lord. To her, all things in life are full of sin, even those that are out of our hands. Carrie’s menstruation is a rite of passage for most young women, but because her mother refused to educate her Carrie sees this coming of age moment as certain death. Her shrieking is a laughable joke to all the other girls. Seeing it from Carrie’s point of view, it must have been terrifying.

Carrie’s telekinetic abilities are never used exploitatively, either. She doesn’t move things with her mind just because she can; the only time her powers come out is when a person has done something cruel or dismissive. She doesn’t fully appreciate her unique abilities, using them as a tool for learning more than anything. Maybe people who do her wrong will think twice the next time, like that little shit on the bike who taunts her as she walks home. These little acts of retaliation are meant to be shocking but harmless. The problem for Carrie is when something so grievous happens to her she enters a catatonic state, emotions erupting from within, and she is nearly blind to her actions.

“Carrie” is less a horror film and more of a dark coming-of-age drama, with aspects that border on comical. Piper Laurie was convinced the script called for humor because her character is so outrageously over the top. She chews so much scenery even a master set consumer like Rod Steiger would be given pause. Chris and Bill’s revenge plot seems a tad farfetched, but you also have to remember kids in high school can be sh*theads; it isn’t so outside the realm of possibility. One thing I still haven’t figured out, no matter how many times I have seen the film, is whether or not Sue and Tommy really care about boosting Carrie’s self-esteem or if it was all just a joke. De Palma suggests their motivations are true but I’m not so sure; I just have a hard time buying it. And that’s part of the fun, I suppose; the ambiguity of those moments. Studios can attempt to recapture the magic of this cinema classic all they want but it just isn’t going to happen. “Carrie” is a bonafide classic; a product of its time, done with style and substance.

Video

MGM issued “Carrie” on Blu-ray years ago, featuring a subpar transfer with a weak encode; it was generally considered to be a flawed release. Scream Factory has trumped that edition considerably, going back to the original negative (something they don’t do often), commissioning a 4K scan that finally allows the film to look as good as it did on theater screens over 40 years ago. The 1.85:1 1080p 24/fps AVC MPEG-4 encoded image is a marked improvement over the last release, featuring tighter contrast, richer blacks, saturated colors, and improved definition. Cinematographer Mario Tosi shot the film with a deliberately gauze-y, dreamy aesthetic that causes many scenes to look soft and smoky. Taking the stylistic choices into consideration, this is still an excellent image filled with fine details and a stronger visual appearance than any home video release.

Audio

Both of Scream Factory’s audio options should please fans of the film, with the choice of either the original English 2.0 mono track or a 5.1 surround sound mix (48kHz/24-bit). If you’re a purist then, by all means, have at it with the mono mix but to my ears the remixed surround sound track is a clear winner. Dialogue sounds richer and clearer, rears are used sparingly to create tension and punch up some of the action, and – most importantly – Pino Donaggio’s absolutely incredible score sounds exquisite pumping through all available speakers. The soundtrack takes viewers on a roller-coaster of emotions, flipping from tragic cues to upbeat Italian funk to emotionally draining melodies. It is often said that score is 50% of a picture’s success and Donaggio’s music holds that adage to be true. Subtitles are available in English for the hearing impaired.

Extras

A wealth of bonus features is nothing new to “Carrie”, as MGM previously included a plethora of material on their special edition releases. Scream Factory not only includes those extras but they have also produced a slew of new ones. Expect to find numerous interviews and plenty of promotional materials.

DISC ONE:

The film’s theatrical trailer (1080p) runs for 2 minutes and 6 seconds.

A “Carrie Franchise Trailer Gallery” (1080p) contains theatrical trailers for both “Carrie” (2002) and “The Rage: Carrie 2” (1999), running for 4 minutes and 12 seconds.

DISC TWO:

Interviews (1080p) contains the following sit-downs:

- “Writing Carrie” runs for 29 minutes and 7 seconds, interviews screenwriter Lawrence D. Cohen.
- “Shooting Carrie” runs for 15 minutes and 22 seconds, interviews director of photography Mario Tosi.
- “Cutting Carrie” runs for 25 minutes and 9 seconds, interviews editor Paul Hirsch.
- “Casting Carrie” runs for 16 minutes and 3 seconds, interviews casting director Harriet B. Helberg.
- “Acting Carrie” runs for 42 minutes and 42 seconds, this archival interview piece features most of the cast & crew.
- “More Acting Carrie” runs for 20 minutes and 19 seconds, with new interviews from members of the cast & crew.
- “Visualizing Carrie” runs for 41 minutes and 33 seconds, with archival interviews from De Palma and others.
- “Bucket of Blood” runs for 23 minutes and 53 seconds, featuring a new interview with composer Pino Donaggio.

“Horror’s Hallowed Grounds” (1080p) featurette revisits the locations of the film, running for 11 minutes and 25 seconds.

“Carrie, The Musical” (1080p) is a featurette that runs for 6 minutes and 23 seconds, looking at the stage play version of the novel.

“More Carrie” (1080p) contains the following promotional materials:

- A collection of five TV spots runs for 3 minutes and 11 seconds.
- Two radio spots run for 1 minute and 29 seconds.
- Still gallery – rare Behind-the-Scenes runs for 4 minutes and 54 seconds, featuring 60 images.
- Still gallery – posters & lobby cards runs for 3 minutes and 56 seconds, featuring 49 images.
- “Stephen King and the Evolution of Carrie" text gallery is a text-based feature that covers the writing of his novel.

Packaging

The two-disc set comes housed in a standard Blu-ray keep case, with each disc on a hub opposite the other. The cover art is reversible. A slip-cover featuring newly created artwork is included on first pressings.

Overall

This is the definitive release for one of the best King adaptations in cinema history. Everything about Scream Factory’s release is a marked improvement over all other home video versions.

The Film: A- Video: B+ Audio: A- Extras: A Overall: A-

 


DVD Compare is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program and the Amazon Europe S.a.r.l. Associates Programme, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.co.uk, amazon.com, amazon.ca, amazon.fr, and amazon.de.