DISC ONE
Episodes (with Play All option):
- #1.01 "Pilot" (23:05)
- #1.02 "Miserable" (22:39)
- #1.03 "Marty's First Date" (22:39)
- #1.04 "Dial 'M' for Mother" (22:49)
- #1.05 "A Little Deb Will Do Ya" (23:18)
- #1.06 "Eyes on the Prize" (22:49)
- #1.07 "Every Doris Has Her Day" (22:38)
- #1.08 "Marathon Mensch" (22:39)
Audio Commentary on "Pilot" with voice actors Maurice LaMarche and Nick Jameson, creators/executive producers/writers Mike Reiss and Al Jean, and director Rich Moore (2004)
Audio Commentary on "Miserable" with creators/executive producers Mike Reiss and Al Jean, writer Steve Levitan, voice actors Nick Jameson, Charles Napier, and Maurice LaMarche producer Rich Moore, and art director David Cutler (2004)
Audio Commentary on "Eyes on the Prize" with creators/executive producers Mike Reiss and Al Jean, voice actors Maurice LaMarche and Nick Jameson, and producer Rich Moore (2004)
Audio Commentary on "Every Doris Has Her Day" by creators/executive producers Mike Reiss and Al Jean, executive producer Jim Brooks, voice actors Nick Jameson, Charles Napier, and Maurice LaMarche producer Rich Moore, and art director David Cutler (2004)
Trailers:
- Contemporary TV (2:06)
- Original Programming TV (2:06)

DISC TWO
Episodes (with Play All option):
- #1.09 "L.A. Jay" (23:00)
- #1.10 "Dr. Jay" (23:01)
- #1.11 "A Day at the Races and A Night at the Opera" (22:43)
- #1.12 "Uneasy Rider" (22:45)
- #1.13 "A Pig-Boy and His Dog" (22:41)
- #2.1 "Sherman, Woman, and Child" (21:44)
- #2.2 "Sherman of Arabia" (21:57)
- #2.3 "A Song for Margo" (22:19)
Audio Commentary on "L.A. Jay" with creators/executive producers/co-writers Mike Reiss and Al Jean, executive producer Jim Brooks, co-writer Steve Levitan, voice actors Nick Jameson, Charles Napier, and Maurice LaMarche, producer Rich Moore, and art director David Cutler (2004)
Audio Commentary on "Sherman, Woman, and Child" with creators/executive producers/writers Al Jean and Mike Reiss, voice actors Maurice LaMarche and Nick Jameson, and producer Rich Moore (2004)
Audio Commentary on "Sherman of Arabia" with creators/executive producers Mike Reiss and Al Jean, voice actors Maurice LaMarche and Nick Jameson, and producer Rich Moore (2004)
"A Pig-Boy and His Dog" storyboard comparison branching featurettes

DISC THREE
Episodes (with Play All option):
- #2.04 "Chunk to Hunk" (22:18)
- #2.05 "Lady Hawke" (22:17)
- #2.06 "Frankie and Ellie Get Lost" (22:07)
- #2.07 "Siskel & Ebert and Jay & Alice" (22:13)
- #2.08 "All the Duke's Men" (22:22)
- #2.09 "Dukerella" (22:20)
- #2.10 "I Can't Believe It's a Clip Show" (22:20)
Audio Commentary on "Siskel & Ebert and Jay & Alice" with creators/executive producers/co-writers Al Jean and Mike Reiss, voice actors Maurice LaMarche and Nick Jameson, and producer Rich Moore (2004)
Trailer Parodies:
- Preview Trivia (1:13)
- Parodies (4:36)
Top Ten List:
- Preview Trivia (1:18)
- List (6:13)
"Creating the Critic":
- Preview Trivia (1:23)
- "Creating the Critic" 2004 featurette (11:48)
Webisodes:
- Preview Trivia (1:24)
- Webisodes (34:24)

None

1.33:1

Non-Anamorphic

NTSC

English Dolby Digital 2.0 stereo

Digipak

Includes a leaflet with an episode guide.
Coded regions 1/2/3/4.